Chapter 4: What It Does Not Do

At ten o’clock the hall was four degrees, and the windows were shut, and four hundred people sat in it in their coats.

David stood at the back.

He had been there since half past nine. He had come in by the side door with the tin and the jar and Josh, and had walked the length of the hall past the rows of benches filling up, past the gold waistcoats and the grey coats and the Honeycomb families who had come in from the sixes with their children, to the three frames under the north windows; and had set the jar on the narrow stone shelf that ran along under the sills, square to the wall, with its cloth off; and had stood beside it, with the frames on his right and the stool on his left and the cold coming up through the floor into his boots.

The hall filled the way water fills a lock, from the bottom. The front benches first, with the grey coats and the gold waistcoats, who had places and knew them; then the middle, the engineers of the Territory in their good dark cloth with their families beside them, children in the same cloth cut smaller, sitting very straight with their hands in their laps as if someone might come along with a ruler; then the back, the sides, the standing places along the walls, where the people from the sixes came in with earth still on their boots and stood with their caps in their hands and looked at the platform and the lamp and did not look at the back of the hall at all, because there was nothing at the back of the hall, as far as Hexam was concerned, but the combs.

His mother was in the second row.

She had turned round once, when she sat down, and found him, and looked at him for exactly as long as it took to see that he was standing up, and turned back. She had the tin’s cloth folded in her lap. His father, beside her, had not turned round. He was sitting with his elbows on his knees and his hands clasped and his eyes on the platform, and David knew the set of those shoulders from the back of the Chococar, and knew that his father was not going to turn round because if he turned round he would not be able to turn back.

Nadia Demir was on the stool. Josh was on the end of it. Neither of them had said anything to him and he had not needed them to. They had said something to each other, once, before he came: he had seen it from the side door, Josh’s head on one side and Nadia’s hand flat on the frame, and had caught, crossing the back of the hall, the end of it. “My teacher sat here before me,” she was saying. “Kwame. He heard them better than I do. He’s not here now.” And Josh had nodded, as if that was a thing he already knew, and she had not said anything else.

The arm was by post.

He had filled it at nine, in the inn, with Sigrun watching: the second cell out of its tin and into the housing, the small deep hum in his teeth, and then the warmth, for about as long as it took to walk across the square. By the hall steps the warmth was a memory. By the frames the joints had gone through awake and thinking-about-it and were at still, and the eight new places under the sleeve, the ones that had moved their eighth of an inch at midnight and had not yet learned where he was, were eight stones that did not know his name.

He flexed the fingers once, under his coat. They came. They came the way a letter comes from a long way off, a day late, with the address slightly wrong.

“Four hundred and six,” said Josh.

He had been counting since half past nine. He had counted the benches and then the people on them and then the people standing at the sides, and had got a number, and had looked at the programme, which said four hundred, and had counted again.

“The programme says four hundred,” said David.

Josh looked at the programme with sympathy, and did not argue with it, and went on being right.

Olivia, in the second row with their parents, had turned round in her seat with her notebook on her knee, and David saw her look at Josh, and then at the programme, and then write something small in a margin with a circle round it, and turn back.

Beatrix Halloran stood on the platform under the lamp with a programme in her hand, and read from it.

She read the whole thing. The Masters’ names, in the order the press had set them: Halvor first, and the hall made a small sound, because every one of the four hundred and six knew the name and most of them knew the story. Then the four others. Then, in the same voice, as if it were the same kind of line as the rest: “Sigrun. Masterwork to be presented by its makers, and by the one who wears it.”

She did not look at the back of the hall when she said it. She folded the programme and put it in her coat and stepped down, and Sigrun stepped up.

Sigrun stood under the lamp with a sheet of drawings pinned to the board behind her and her hands at her sides, and said what it was.

She said it the way she said everything, as a measurement. Dwarven steel, from the lower veins, so many parts in so many. The housing, chocolate-reinforced, cast in two halves. The joints, caramel crystal, cut from a block cut from a vein in the hills, eleven joints, each ground to a tolerance she named. The sleeve, gummy compound, poured to a form taken from the shoulder at the first fitting and re-taken at every fitting since. The cell. The oil. The hook, and the housing it lived in, and the homing crystal that brought it back.

The hall was quiet in the way the Stonework were quiet, which was a listening quiet, with pencils in it.

David had never heard the arm described.

He had worn it since the spring. He had oiled it and filled it and broken four cups with it and slept with the weight of it on the wrong side of him and never once heard anyone say, in order, in a level voice, what it was; and standing at the back of the hall hearing it he found that it was like hearing your own name read out from a list. It was his and it was not. Eleven joints. He had never counted them. Two halves to the housing. He had not known there was a seam. He put his left hand up, under his coat, to the plate, and found the seam with his thumb, there, where she said, a hairline, and took the hand away again.

In the second row his father had leaned forward. Not much. The width of a hand. His chin had come up off his clasped fists and his eyes had gone from the platform to the drawings pinned on the board behind it, and stayed there, and David could see, even from the back, the thing come into his face that had come into it at the stove with the pan: the look of a man watching a thing go.

Then she said: “What it does not do.”

She said it plainly, and the pencils stopped.

“It does not grow. The wearer grows. Every month I move the fittings an eighth of an inch and for two days, or three, the arm does not know him. It does not warm itself. The cell warms it, and the cell is filled by hand, and the wearer forgets, as any wearer would. It does not hold a grip between fittings. The grip is set, and it drifts, and in the fourth week it is nowhere. It does not know it is at dinner. The hook fires when the fist closes past a point, and the fist closes past that point when the grip has drifted, and the hook does not ask. Its recall is direct. It does not go round.” She paused. “It was reset last night, after the dinner. It is on a boy who cannot yet hold a cup with it. I present it as it is, this morning, in this cold, because that is what it is.”

She looked at the back of the hall.

“The wearer will now touch the jar,” she said. “It is a piece of glass. It rings. The joints answer it. I do not know why. I will not say I do.”

Four hundred and six heads turned.

He put his finger out.

He had done it a hundred times. On the sill at home, in the sun, in the dark; in the hall three days ago, through wood, to the wrist. He put the steel forefinger on the cold stone shelf an inch from the jar, lightly, the way you’d touch a thing to see if the paint was wet, and the jar rang.

One note. So low you’d have thought it was the floor. It went along the shelf and into the stone and out across the hall in the silence, and he felt it arrive at the finger.

And stop there.

Nothing came up. The finger took the note the way a step takes a foot, and held it, and did not pass it on; the joint above it was a stone that did not know his name, and the note went into it and went no further, and the hall waited, and he stood with his finger on the shelf and the whole of Hexam looking at the back of his head and felt the heat come into his face and nothing come into his arm.

He kept the finger there.

He did not know, afterwards, how long. Long enough for the silence to change its shape. Long enough for Josh, on the end of the stool, to put both hands flat on the frame of the third comb, because he could not help it.

Then the combs answered.

They had heard the jar. They did not need the arm to tell them; the note had gone across the stone floor and into the frames the way it had at the dinner, and the three sheets of comb took it and gave it back, wide and low and warm, the hum with no direction, so that the whole back of the hall was speaking in one voice; and that voice came back along the shelf, and into the finger, from the other side, and this time it did not stop. It was wider than the jar’s note. It did not need a path. It came up the finger and into the hand and found the first stone, and went round it, and the next, and went round that; and at the wrist it arrived, and stayed, warm, exactly as far as the wrist, and no further; and the eight places under the sleeve, far above, stayed stones.

He heard it. The hall heard it. Four hundred and six people heard a piece of glass on a shelf and three frames of comb and a steel arm hold one note together for the space of a breath, and the crystal in the knuckles of the hand glow, faintly, with a light that was the colour of the oil.

Then he took the finger off, and it stopped.

“To the wrist,” said Sigrun, from the platform, into the silence, in her measuring voice. “Through a reset. It is the first time. I did not know.”

In the second row the Queen had both hands flat on the folded cloth in her lap, pressing it, as if it might get up. The King had not moved. Olivia had not written anything. She was looking at the back of the hall with her pencil an inch above the page and her mouth a little open, and then she shut her mouth, and looked down, and wrote one line, short, and underlined it, which she did not do.

Beatrix Halloran, at the side of the platform, had her hand on the yard ruler where it leaned against the step, and had not picked it up.

At the side door, Farida Osei, who had come in late with her hands in her coat and stood against the wall, had shut her eyes.

The silence went on for a while after that.

It was the Stonework silence. David had been told about it, by Sigrun, with a drawing: that when the Masters saw a work they did not clap, or speak, or nod, but sat, and looked, and let it be there; and that the length of the silence was the assessment, and that a long one was good. This one went on long enough for the braziers at the sides, which had been lit at nine for form’s sake, to go grey. It went on long enough for Josh to take his hands off the frame. Halvor sat in the front row at the centre with his gloved hand in his lap and his bare one on his knee and did not move at all.

Then the questions.

They came from the Masters, one after another, exact, in flat voices, and Sigrun answered each one from the platform in the same voice, and David understood perhaps one in three. The tolerance of the third joint. The pour temperature of the sleeve. The cell’s draw in the cold against its draw in the warm, in units he did not know. A Master at the end of the row, Signe, a woman with a notch out of the top of one ear, asked about the oil: “Almond. From which press?” and Sigrun named a press, and the woman wrote it down with the air of somebody who had been waiting to know for some time.

At the far end of the front row, in the good dark coat, with his hat on his knee, the man who had not touched his water sat with a small notebook open and wrote, once, one word, and shut it.

The questions went on. A Master called Brynjar asked whether the sleeve could be poured to the shoulder cold, and Sigrun said no, and said why, and the Master nodded as if he had thought not. A Master called Torunn asked what happened to the third joint during the note, and Sigrun said that she had measured it at noon the day before and would measure it again at noon today and did not yet know, and the Master wrote noon and underlined it. One of the gold waistcoats, a woman with grey hair pinned up hard, asked how the eighth of an inch was decided, and Sigrun said, “By the boy,” and the woman waited for the rest, and there was no rest, and she wrote that down too.

Olivia was writing without looking down. David could see the pencil going from the back. She had a page for this; she would have made one on the tram. It would say Questions at the top in the certain colour and under it, in the uncertain, every one, in order, with the answer and whether the answer was a number, and he knew without being able to see it that there was a mark beside the ones that were not.

Then Halvor.

He did not stand. He sat where he was with his gloved hand in his lap and said, without raising his voice, so that the hall had to lean to hear it, and did:

“Where does it hurt when the hook comes home?”

Sigrun did not answer. David saw her not answer: saw her open her mouth, and understand the question, and close it, and look down the hall at him; because the question was not about the arm, and she did not say what was not so, and she did not know.

The hall turned round.

He could have moved the hand. That was what he had said he would do, on the first Tuesday, in the breakfast room: you will move the hand when I say move the hand. He could have flexed the fingers, slowly, by post, and let the hall see them come, and let that be the answer, and Sigrun would have said something exact about the housing and the hall would have nodded and written it down. He could feel the answer sitting in the arm, ready. It would have been easy. It would have been like standing under the lamp.

“At the shoulder,” said David.

His voice went up the hall. It was not a big voice. It was the only one.

“Where the sleeve comes in. There are eight places where the fitting meets me, and when the hook goes out they pull, all eight, forward, like somebody’s got hold of my coat from the front. And when it comes home they pull the other way, back, hard, once. Like being pulled up short.” He stopped. His face was hot and the rest of him was not. “And then at night. They’re cold. Eight of them. Like coins. After a refit they’re stones. It’s the first day after a refit now, so they’re stones.” He looked at Halvor. “That’s where.”

The hall did not say anything.

Halvor looked at him for a long moment with his square brown face and his hedge of a beard. Then he took his bare hand off his knee, and put it to the button at the wrist of the glove, and undid it, and drew the glove off.

The hand under it was steel.

It was old steel, dull, worn bright at the knuckles with forty years of use, and smaller than David’s, and finer, and the joints of it were not caramel but something darker, amber gone to brown; and where it met the wrist, under the cuff of the grey coat, David could see, because he was looking for them now, the places. Eight. Set in a ring where the metal met the man, each one a small worn dimple in the skin, like the marks a chair leaves in a carpet when it has stood there for a very long time.

Halvor held the hand up, so that the hall could see it. He turned it over, palm up, palm down, the way David turned his in the sun. He did not say anything.

Then he put the glove back on, and buttoned it, and put the hand in his lap.

That was all.

It was not all, for the hall. David could feel that. The silence had changed again, into a thing with a different weight, and it was not pointed at him any more; it had gone to the front row, to the square grey figure with the gloved hand, and it stayed there, and the four Masters on either side of him did not look at him, with great care, the way you do not look at somebody who has just said something in a room where it has never been said.

Sigrun, on the platform, had put one brick-coloured hand on the edge of the board behind her, and was holding it.

The next question came from a gold waistcoat.

He stood up to ask it, which the Masters had not; a tall man with a neat beard and a neat voice, two rows behind Halvor, whom David had seen at the top table at the dinner and had not been told the name of. He was told it now, because the man gave it: “Piet Rasmus, senior engineer, for the Territory.” He gave it to the platform, not to the back of the hall, and he asked his question of Sigrun, and he asked it politely, and it was a real question.

“Master Sigrun. The work is remarkable. I ask as an engineer, not as a critic.” He looked at his notes. “The housing is cast to a different line from the wearer’s other arm. The steel is bare. The joints are visible. The proportions are a Stonework proportion, not the wearer’s own. In the Territory we would say the work does not match its context.” He looked up. “Could it not be made to look like the other?”

Sigrun opened her mouth.

“Why would I want it to look normal,” said David, from the back, “if it can do more?”

He had not meant to say it. It was out before he knew it was coming, the way the hook went; and it went down the hall the same way, straight, through whatever was in front of it, and arrived at Piet Rasmus and stopped him with his mouth a little open and his notes in his hand.

David did not say anything else. He found he did not want to. The thing was said and it was true and he did not need it twice.

Piet Rasmus looked at the platform, and at Sigrun, who was looking at the back of the hall with her grey eyes and an expression David had never seen on her and could not read; and then he looked at Halloran, who was standing at the side of the platform with her ruler, and who met his eye and said nothing at all; and then he sat down, slowly, and wrote something on his notes, and crossed it out.

At the far end of the front row the man in the dark coat opened his notebook, and wrote a second word, and shut it again.

The hall broke at noon, when the sun got on the roof and Halloran had the north windows opened for the combs, and four hundred and six people stood up in the cold and went out into the warm square talking.

David went out by the side door. Farida was still against the wall by it, with her hands in her coat, and she did not move as he came past, and did not say anything until he was level with her, and then said, to the opposite wall: “They heard it.”

“The bees did.”

“That’s what I said.” She took one hand out of her coat and put it, briefly, on the shoulder plate, on the angle, the way the Queen had; and took it away; and went out ahead of him into the sun without looking back, down the slope toward the hollow, where there was work to do.

Olivia caught him on the steps. She had the notebook open at the page and she held it so he could see: Questions, in the certain colour, and a column, and beside the column the marks. Fourteen questions. Eleven numbers. Three marks.

“Which three,” he said.

“The third joint. The eighth of an inch.” She shut the book. “Where it hurts.”

The Masters’ workshop was behind the hall, through a door David had not noticed, down three steps, in a long low room the Territory had lent for the week.

It had been a store for the combs once; you could tell from the hooks in the ceiling beams and the sweet old smell in the plaster. The Dwarves had made it theirs in a day. Five benches, one each, with the black cases open on them and the trays out and the tools laid in rows, and five lamps, and on a sixth bench by the wall, under a window with the sun coming in low and gold through it at last, the arm.

Sigrun had taken it off at noon.

She had wanted a second look at the housing after the hook, and at the fittings after the hall, and at the jar’s effect on the third joint, which had done something during the note that she wished to measure; and she had taken it off in the workshop, on the bench, in the sun, and looked, and measured, and written three lines in a book, and said “Good,” which was the second time that month, and then been called away to the platform by Halloran about the afternoon.

So David sat on a stool by the bench with his shirt off his right shoulder and the eight places open to the warm, and the arm beside him in the sun, and the ghost pressure going: a thumb being pressed, a long way off, by somebody kind.

He was not thinking about anything. That was the odd part. He had stood in front of four hundred and six people and said where it hurt, and a Master had taken his glove off, and a senior engineer had sat down; and he had thought he would be thinking about all of it, and he was not. He was watching the sun move along the steel. He was smelling almonds. He had the oil can in his left hand, and was turning it, and the warmth of the room had got into the eight places and turned the stones to coins, and the coins were warm.

The door at the top of the three steps opened.

“Is this the Stonework?” said a voice. “I’ve got an oil.”

It was a girl.

She was about his height, or a little less, with black hair cut straight across her forehead and straight across the back of her neck, as if with the same ruler, and a brown canvas coat too big for her with the sleeves turned up twice, and a paper in her hand. She had the look of the updraft ports: the squint that comes from looking at a lot of sky. She came down the three steps without waiting to be asked, which in Hexam was itself a thing, and stopped at the bottom and looked round the five benches for a Dwarf and did not find one.

Then she found the sixth bench. And the arm on it. And him.

She looked at the arm for a while. She looked at it the way everybody did, down the length of it, from the shoulder plate to the fingertips lying open in the sun; and then she looked at the empty place at his shoulder, and the eight places; and then at his face.

“Oh,” she said. “You’re the one who wears it.”

“Yes.”

“I’m Ren. Takagi. My father’s got the oil contract.” She held up the paper, which was a docket, with a column of figures and a stamp. “Almond. Pressed Above, from the groves on the south cliffs. The Masters have been buying it off us for eleven years and I’ve never seen what they put it in.” She looked at the arm again. “That’s what they put it in.”

“Yes.”

She came over.

She did not ask if she could. She came and stood on the other side of the bench with the sun between them and the arm in it, and looked at it close, with her hands behind her back, the way you look at something in a shop that you have been told not to touch and do not need to; and she looked for a long time. He watched her look. He waited for the question. He knew the question; he had been asked it, in one form or another, by every stranger since the spring, kindly, with the face that went with it, and he had an answer that was true and short and that he had got very good at saying.

“How often does the grip drift?” said Ren.

He looked at her.

“Between fittings,” she said. “She said in the hall it’s set and it drifts and by the fourth week it’s nowhere. Is it the same every month? Does it drift the same way every time, or does it wander?” She looked up from the arm. “Because if it’s the same way, you could allow for it. You’d know where it had gone to before she came. But if it wanders you can’t, and that’d be worse, and you’d break things.”

“It wanders,” said David.

“Both ways?”

“Both ways. Some months it closes too far and some months it won’t close. I don’t know till I pick something up.”

“Hm.” She looked at the hand. “And it’s the whole hand or one finger?”

“The thumb goes first. Always the thumb. Then the rest follow it.”

“So the thumb’s the one that’s wrong, and the others are only copying.” She looked at the joints with her head on one side. “Has she tried setting the thumb separately?”

He had no idea. He said so. She asked how the cell was filled and he told her, and she asked how long a cell lasted in the cold against the warm and he told her that too, in the units he did know, which were mornings; and she asked about the recall, and what the hook’s line was made of, and whether the homing crystal was the same cut as the joints, and he answered what he could and said I don’t know to the rest, and she wrote the I don’t knows on the back of her father’s docket in a square pressed hand, in a list, as if they were an order to be filled.

The sun moved along the bench. It went off the fingers and along the forearm and up to the shoulder plate and off the bench altogether, and neither of them noticed, because by then she was telling him how the updraft pilots judged the wind on the south cliffs with a thread tied to a thumb, and he was telling her how Josh counted things, and the lamp on Sigrun’s bench had gone down and needed filling and neither of them had filled it.

She told him about the groves. The almond trees grew on the south cliffs in terraces cut by people who had come up the updrafts a long time ago and had not gone back, and the oil came down to the ports in casks on a cable that her father had rebuilt twice and swore at daily, and the Dwarves had been the first to buy it, eleven years ago, and had never once said what for. “He thought it was for lamps,” she said. “He’s been telling people for eleven years it’s for lamps.” She looked at the arm with satisfaction. “I’m going to enjoy this.”

He told her about the Touch test, and the Chococar, and the day the new one went three kilometres.

“What’s the thumb for,” he said, when she had stopped laughing about the Chococar. “You keep looking at mine. The thumb.”

“Do I?” She looked at it again, on the bench, lying open in the last of the sun. “It’s the one you’d tie the thread to.”

“What thread?”

She held up her own left hand, with the thumb out, as if she were hitching a ride, and squinted at it.

“On the cliffs. The pilots. Before a cask goes down the cable they tie a thread to their thumb, one thread, off a spun-sugar twist, as fine as that.” She nodded at the oil can’s spout. “And they hold the hand up, like this, and they read the wind off it. Which way it’s leaning. How much. Whether it’s going to change.” She put the hand down. “My father can’t do it. He’s tried for thirty years. He holds his thumb up and the thread does what the thread does and he can’t see it.” She shrugged. “I can. I could when I was six. I don’t know why. It’s not a thing you learn.”

“What does it tell you?”

“Where the wind is.” She looked at the arm. “That’s all. It doesn’t change the wind. It doesn’t send the cask down any faster. It just means you know.” She was quiet for a moment. “Which is the only thing worth knowing,” she said, and then looked as if she had not meant to say that, and went back to the arm.

He asked her, at some point, what the surface looked like from the ports; and she said, “Like the bottom of a bowl,” and then, “You can’t see it. It’s cloud. You feel the updraft on your face and you know it’s there, that’s all,” and he thought about the shaft on Level Three, and the Stone going down it with its head turned, and did not say so.

“You’re not finished,” said Josh, from the top of the steps.

He had been sent to find David for supper. He stood in the doorway with Glowey and looked at the two of them, in the half dark, on either side of a bench with an arm on it, and said it the way he said things that had come up and were true, and went away again to say so to the Queen.

Ren looked at the dark window.

“That’s two hours,” she said. “My father will have gone.” She did not sound as if this was a disaster. She picked up the docket, and looked at the back of it, at her list, and at the front of it, at the stamp, and tore the front from the back along the fold, and put the half with the stamp in her coat, and put the half with the list on the bench, by the shoulder plate, square, the way Olivia put things down.

“That’s for the Master,” she said. “The questions. If she wants them.” She went to the steps. At the bottom she stopped, and looked back, not at the arm, at him. “Does it wander?” she said. “You should keep a page. Which way, each month. Then you’d know.”

She went up the steps and out.

David sat in the dark workshop with his shirt off his shoulder and the eight places warm and the arm lying beside him on the bench with the sun gone off it, and looked at the piece of docket with the list on it, and found that his face was doing something he had not told it to, and let it.

His father was on the landing again.

David came up the inn stairs with the half docket in his left hand and the eight places warm under the sleeve for the first time since midnight, and his father was at the top, with a candle, in his shirtsleeves, as if he had been there since the last time and the nights in between had not happened.

He looked at David. He looked at the arm. Then he said, quite quietly, in the ordinary voice he used for the thumb and the pan:

“At the shoulder.”

“Yes.”

His father nodded. He did not say anything else. He stood a moment longer with the candle, and David understood, looking at him, that his father had not known.

The King put his hand on top of David’s head, the way he had at dawn, and left it there a second longer than that, and went down.

“She asked about your mind,” said Olivia that night. “Not your arm.”

She was sitting on the end of his bed with her notebook shut on her knee. She had not opened it. She had come in to say goodnight, which she did not usually do, and had sat down instead, and had asked him, in her plain way, what the girl with the docket had wanted, and he had told her: the grip, the drift, the thumb, the cell, the thread on the pilot’s thumb, the two hours.

David looked at the sill.

The jar was there, square to the frame, with the moon on it. Beside it, where the matchbox would have been at home, was the half docket, with the list on it in the square pressed hand, weighted at one corner with the oil can so it would not go anywhere.

“…Yes,” he said.

Olivia nodded, once, as if a column had come out, and got up, and went.

Previous chapter · All chapters · Next chapter